-
Healthcare
-

A National Patient Record Is Being Built Before Parliament Has Settled Who Controls It

By
Distilled Post Editorial Team

Consider a woman at thirty-four weeks of pregnancy, sitting in an assessment unit while a midwife she has never met asks whether she has experienced a previous loss. She gave the same answer at her GP surgery on Monday and again at a scan on Wednesday. Each repetition costs her something, and each clinician works from a fragment. Nobody who has spent time on a maternity ward or in a frailty clinic needs persuading that this is a failure worth fixing. The case for a single patient record is strong, and it commands support across both Houses of Parliament.

That consensus is why the sequence of events this month deserves attention. NHS England has awarded CGI IT UK a one-year interim contract worth £47.7m to design, build and support the core platform, running from 2 November 2026 to 1 November 2027. The legislation that would require GP practices and NHS organisations to share patient information is still before the House of Lords, where peers began their line-by-line examination of the bill on 28 October. The commissioner is buying the foundations while Parliament is still deciding what may be built on them.

Procurement ahead of legislation is not improper. Public bodies routinely commission design work on a timetable that anticipates royal assent, and a twelve-month term limits the exposure. Government intends the record to reach patients through the NHS App from 2028, starting with maternity and frailty, and a build beginning in 2026 fits that ambition. The difficulty lies in what an early commitment does to the politics of scrutiny. Once a supplier is mobilised and a public date is attached to a clinical pathway, every amendment tabled in the Lords can be framed as a threat to a programme already under way. Peers are invited to examine a framework while the executive is already pouring concrete.

The amendments at issue are substantial. The BMA has warned that the bill risks removing the requirement to seek patient consent before GP data is shared, and has asked peers to ensure the common law duty of confidentiality continues to apply to the record. It has also argued that the standards of transparency and accountability which bound NHS England must bind the Health Secretary once that body is gone. This second point is easily overlooked. The bill abolishes NHS England and transfers its powers to the Secretary of State. The organisation that signed this contract will not exist in its present form when the contract ends, and the minister who inherits its data powers will do so under a legal framework that is still being amended. Accountability for the record is being rewritten at the same moment as the record is being built.

Some of the alarm about centralisation deserves tempering. NHS England's chief digital officer has said the record will connect existing systems and will not become a huge data lake, and the design under test is more federated than the phrase national database implies. A federated design does not answer the legal question of who may see what, and on what terms. The bill answers that, and it is the part still in committee. MPs who examined it supported the concept and pressed for adequate privacy safeguards, which suggests the concern runs across parties.

Trust is a practical matter here. GPs write their notes on the understanding that a patient and a small team will read them. If patients conclude that a consultation may be read by a registrar in another county, and that consent no longer governs access, some will say less. Clinicians would then work from a thinner record than they have today, and the service will have spent £47.7m degrading its own raw material. The national programme for IT, abandoned in 2011 after consuming billions, taught the NHS that clinical engagement cannot be added to architecture that has already been bought. Leaders who were in post then will recognise the pattern.

The practical consequences differ by audience. Trust executives asked to prepare for wider record visibility by next spring should treat the dates as contingent on royal assent and on whatever consent provisions survive the Lords. Integrated care boards and trusts that have invested in local shared care records need clarity on whether that spending is protected or duplicated, a concern suppliers with established products have already raised. GPs carry the sharpest exposure, since their data is the prize and their duty of confidentiality is the point under negotiation. Suppliers, including CGI, should expect that a design built on assumptions about consent may need rework if peers succeed in amending the bill.

Patients are owed a plain account. The government's case rests on a promise of real control over personal data, and that promise should be tested against the text of the bill rather than the language of a press release. Peers are the ones doing the testing, and the quality of their scrutiny will determine whether the promise holds.

The interim contract expires on 1 November 2027, close to the point when the legal settlement will have met its first practical test. Ministers can protect both timetables by accepting amendments that anchor consent and confidentiality in statute, which would allow the supplier's plan to proceed on firm ground. If they resist, the programme will ask a sceptical public to trust a record whose legal terms were settled after the money was spent. The success of the single patient record is being decided in a Lords committee room, and the delivery plan is secondary to it.