-
Business
-

Treasury Pushes Back Against Proposed Youth National Insurance Cut

By
Distilled Post Editorial Team

Treasury officials are resisting a recommendation from Alan Milburn's review of youth employment to cut employer National Insurance contributions (NICs) for workers aged 21 to 24. Insiders argue that the policy would be prohibitively expensive and would do little to reduce youth unemployment. The disagreement has surfaced ahead of forthcoming budget decisions, leaving ministers to weigh the review's findings against the pressure on the public finances.

Mr Milburn's central proposal is to double the earnings threshold at which employers begin paying NICs on staff in this age group, from £5,000 to £10,000. Under the current arrangement, a business pays the levy on every pound a young employee earns above the lower figure. Raising the threshold would reduce the bill for each person hired in the age bracket.

The review suggests the change should be introduced gradually over five years, with the pace depending on economic conditions. It recommends that the relief go first to sectors with a high proportion of young workers, among them retail and hospitality. Its stated aim is to encourage employers to take on young people who are not in education, employment or training, a group commonly described as NEETs.

The measure would amount to a partial reversal of the increase in employer NICs announced in 2024 by Rachel Reeves, then Chancellor. That rise lowered the threshold and raised the rate, and businesses across the economy have since cited it as a reason for holding back on recruitment, particularly of entry-level staff.

Within the Treasury, the view is that a broad tax cut of this kind represents poor value for public money. Officials point out that the relief would apply to every employer hiring in the age group, including those who would have recruited young people regardless. Money would therefore flow to many firms whose hiring decisions were unaffected.

The department's scepticism draws on modelling by the Resolution Foundation. The think tank estimated that raising the threshold to £9,100 for under-25s would cost roughly £1bn a year. It put the number of additional jobs created at around 7,000, which works out at approximately £137,000 for each extra worker hired. Treasury figures regard that ratio as difficult to defend when departments are competing for limited funds, and some argue that targeted schemes, such as wage subsidies tied to long-term unemployment, would reach the intended group at lower cost.

Downing Street has taken a more measured line. Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, has endorsed the broad objective of tackling youth joblessness and has promised a swift review of the report. His officials maintain, however, that changes to tax rates and thresholds are a matter for the formal budget process and cannot be settled in advance of it. That position leaves the Chancellor free to accept the review's diagnosis of the problem while declining its preferred remedy.

The delay is unwelcome to employers. Trade bodies representing retailers and hospitality businesses have warned that Treasury opposition weakens efforts to recruit young people, many of whom start their careers in shops, restaurants, pubs and hotels. They argue that hiring will not recover unless the ongoing payroll tax burden falls, and that one-off grants or training schemes cannot replace a lasting reduction in the cost of employing someone. Several have said that margins in their sectors are already thin, so each increase in labour costs makes a marginal vacancy harder to justify.

Youth unemployment has remained a political concern, with the number of NEETs drawing attention from both sides of the Commons. The review gives ministers a detailed set of options, but the Treasury's objections suggest that the NICs proposal faces the stiffest resistance of any of them. Whether the Chancellor adopts it in full, modifies it or sets it aside will become clear only when the budget is delivered.